ASF header

 
Uzbekistan's proactive response to COVID-19 should see a full reopening of the economy by 10th May.
 

 

AFC Uzbekistan Fund April 2020 Update

 

Dear Investors and Friends,

April was a quiet month in Uzbekistan, like in many parts of the rest of the world, as the quarantine in the country was extended to 10th May since the number of infections rose sharply during the month, peaking at 2,017 (bear in mind that the population of Uzbekistan is 34 mln). Though, in the past several weeks the government has been testing 10,000 people per day and active cases have been in decline, currently 904. During the last week of April, the government permitted a slow reopening of the economy with businesses including construction markets, auto dealerships and parts suppliers, notaries, dry cleaners and craftsmen to reopen and personal cars to be back on the road for several hours during the morning and evening. With active cases tapering off, it is expected that the quarantine won’t be extended past 10th May and the opening of the economy will accelerate.

With Uzbekistan in quarantine for the full month of April, volume at the stock exchange was lighter than usual and the Uzbek Som experienced a decrease of 5.4% versus the USD. The reason for the decline of the Uzbek Som was that the Central Bank lowered its policy rate from 16% to 15% in order to stimulate growth and ease pressure on borrowers, which is discussed in further depth below. The April NAV of the fund decreased to an estimated USD 970 (-2.0%), according to internal calculations.

AFC Uzbekistan Fund valuations as of 30th April 2020:

Estimated weighted harmonic average trailing P/E (only companies with profit): 3.70x
Estimated weighted harmonic average P/B: 0.62x
Estimated weighted portfolio dividend yield: 4.92%

 

Global cost-push inflation to bolster Uzbekistan’s medium-term macro story:

As the global economy undergoes a deflationary collapse with Central Banks trying their hardest to re-inflate bubbles through money printing in an attempt to pave over the cracks caused by COVID-19. Looking beyond the current crisis when things begin to normalize it is becoming increasingly likely that we will be entering a period of heightened inflation. With regionalisation gaining traction (i.e. Japan announcing it will provide USD 2 bln in subsidies for factories looking to relocate out of China), strained supply chains (multiple meat processing plants in USA are shuttered due to COVID-19 outbreaks) and the coming labour demands as economies reopen and dedicated hygiene staff are required to spray sanitizer on customers hands at supermarkets, malls and schools and sanitize public spaces, all of these events are inherently inflationary.

Looking at this “costlier” economic situation on the horizon, we have spent a lot of time questioning whether Uzbekistan will benefit from this new environment and if so how. The answer we have concluded is: Yes! Uzbekistan will benefit and the country could be one of the major (Asian) beneficiaries of global inflation pressures due to its self-reliance courtesy of its large domestic agricultural and manufacturing industries, cheap and abundant labour pool and endowment of commodities.

Uranium to benefit Uzbekistan’s economy:

Having written about the benefit gold provides Uzbekistan in last month’s fund update, uranium is another commodity which contributes sizably to Uzbekistan’s economy with the country supplying 4.5% of global production. Uranium is the main material in the global nuclear reactor fleet (there are 450 reactors operating globally with 54 under construction, helping the industry to grow 2% per year), and since the nuclear meltdown at the Fukushima Daiichi power plant in Japan in 2011 the price of uranium has fallen from over USD 70 per pound to the high teens in 2016. The uranium price collapse led to significant underinvestment and inhibited new mine production as western countries focused on shutting down their power plants with nuclear energy falling out of favour. However, this negative sentiment has receded in recent years as nuclear energy is the only carbon-free source of baseload power. The price slump led Cameco Corporation, a Canadian uranium producer, and Kazatomprom, Kazakhstan’s state-owned uranium producer, to announce production cuts and mine closures in 2017.

Fast forward to 2020 and the uranium market was already in a deficit to the tune of roughly 30 to 40 mln pounds, while annual demand stands at approximately 200 mln pounds. On 7th April 2020 Kazatomprom, with 41% of global market share, announced it would be curtailing production for three months at all of its sites and decrease its onsite worker headcount to comply with lockdowns in Kazakhstan. Similar shutdowns have also occurred with Cameco Corporation in Canada and mining operations in Namibia, accelerating the deficit to around 80 mln pounds today. This supply shock, compounded by severe under-investment in the industry over the past decade has led to a structural shortage where existing mine production, and idle capacity available to come online, is now insufficient to meet the demand of the growing industry. This means either prices must rise to incentivise new mine development or 14% of global electricity supply is at risk of shutting down.

During this virus period Uzbekistan’s uranium mines, located in the Navoi region, specifically around the city of Uchkuduk, have been running uninhibited and with their first quartile cost of production are poised to benefit from the uptrend in prices, estimated to contribute up to an additional USD 500 mln to GDP, as prices have already risen +42% from their recent low on 23rd March, 2020 and +34% YTD.

 

1-year uranium price

(Source: Bloomberg)

 

As cost-push inflation comes to the fore due to demand for goods where investment in production has been insufficient in recent years, Uzbekistan is poised to benefit, either through the ability to supply its domestic demand for goods (food and consumer electronics) or being a net-exporter of goods (uranium, gold, steel, produce) which will support the economy and see the country’s already robust USD 30 bln foreign exchange war chest grow yet further.

Central Bank & finance news:

The first quarter saw Uzbekistan’s GDP grow 4.1%, down from 5.7% but still robust when considering China, Uzbekistan’s second largest trading partner, was in lockdown for most of the quarter.

In response to the softness in the economy brought on by the spread of COVID-19, on 14th April the Central Bank of Uzbekistan lowered its policy rate from 16% to 15% as part of a multi-pronged approach by the government to stimulate the economy. Unlike in western countries, Uzbekistan is very traditional in that since it still has positive interest rates and cares more about returning to a trade surplus than relying on helicopter money to stimulate the economy. In fact, during the month, Russian economist Sergey Guriev suggested the government to follow the USA and implement helicopter money policy to which President Mirziyoyev immediately shot down as a foolish and unsound idea.

The decrease in the Central Bank policy rate however did cause the Uzbek Som (UZS) to depreciate against the USD by 5.4% during the month. Though, the currency is still much stronger relative to the majority of its peers in Central Asia and the Caucuses as Russia, Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan saw their currencies depreciate by 19.7%, 13.3% and 11.3% respectively while UZS is down only 6.5% YTD. Due to Uzbekistan’s free-floating currency and diversified economy (~55% of whose GDP is generated by SME’s while ~70% of Kazakh and ~50% of Russian GDP is generated from government) the currency should remain an outperformer relative to its peers. Further, while the collapse in oil prices hurt Russia and Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan was impacted to a much lesser degree as its main hydrocarbon export is natural gas which saw much less demand destruction. It is also worth re-iterating from the March fund update that by the middle of the 2020’s Uzbekistan is focused on stopping gas exports altogether and will instead focus on expanding domestic processing capacity of value-added products including plastics, CNG and fertilizers for export.

 

Free-floating Uzbek Som dramatically outperforms its peers

 

(Source: Bloomberg)

TBC Bank receives full banking license:

During the month the Central Bank issued Georgian bank TBC a full banking license. TBC plans to roll out a digital banking solution in June which should be attractive to consumers both due to competitive rates and the ease of physical distancing rather than walking into a traditional bank branch. As discussed before, TBC’s plans for the aggressive rollout of its digital banking platform should help to stimulate a competitive spirit among local banks, improving customer service, rates and efficiency, all of which should be welcomed by customers.

Company news:

In April two of the fund’s top five portfolio holdings reported positive developments in their businesses:

The Uzbek Commodities Exchange (URTS), a platform similar to the COMEX or NYMEX, announced on 1st April 2020 that it conducted the first forward (derivatives) contract in Uzbek history. The contract was for delivery of UZS 27.5 bln (~USD 2.7 mln) worth of sugar 60 days forward. This is very significant as during our meetings with management we had been informed that the exchange was working on developing a derivatives trading business for the exchange, which has come online ahead of schedule and this will obviously be very good for future earnings growth. Prior to the introduction of derivatives, the exchange was merely a digital bazaar with every buyer intending to take physical delivery of a particular commodity. The exchange also reported first quarter 2020 earnings which grew +8% year over year while book value grew +232% yoy. URTS currently trades at a trailing 12 month P/E of 7.34x and P/B of 1.41x, which is inexpensive when considering the growth potential of the existing physical trading business as well as the commencement of derivatives trading, the latter of which opens the door for hedgers and investors which will drive further commission revenue.

The fund’s largest holding, Kizilqum Cement (QZSM) also had good news during the month, reporting first quarter 2020 earnings on 21st April which were very strong. The company saw +103% earnings growth year on year. Currently, QZSM trades at a trailing 12 month P/E of 2.33x, P/B of 0.42x and 1.18x cash (the company has no debt). The broader construction industry largely continued operating during the quarantine, and while some softness in second quarter numbers is expected, they should hold up relatively well, especially as infrastructure projects are brought forward to help stimulate the economy. Additionally, on 24th April 2020 the Uzbek government announced a ban on all imported cement for the remainder of 2020 in order to support domestic producers. 

For further viewing here are some interesting, relevant news links related to Uzbekistan: 

Uzbekistan carries out 10,000 coronavirus tests a day

Uzbekistan allows construction markets, auto retailers and others to reopen

Uzbekistan seeks end of cotton boycott

Subscriptions

The next cutoff date for new subscriptions will be 25th May 2020. If you would like any assistance with the subscription process please get in touch with us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Best regards,

Scott Osheroff

CIO AFC Uzbekistan Fund